Whoopie Pies from Whoopie Bakery
Looking to order Whoopie Pies online? You came to the right place! You can pick from one of our favorite combinations or make your own!
Deluxe Whoopie Pies
Chocolate cakes, caramel glaze, crushed chocolate covered coffee beans, and cinnamon espresso filling
Orange bottom cake, vanilla glaze, maraschino cherries, roasted coconut, pineapple filling, vanilla top cake
Christmas in the Fall
Gingerbread bottom cake, vanilla glaze, roasted almonds, cream cheese filling, pumpkin cake top
Chocolate cakes, chocolate glaze, mini chocolate chips, chocolate filling
Vanilla bottom cake, chocolate glaze, maraschino cherries, vanilla filling, chocolate top cake
Chocolate Whoopie Pie cakes with caramel glaze, vanilla filling, toasted pecans, and mini chocolate chips.
The Birthday Party
Vanilla cakes, vanilla glaze, rainbow sprinkles, and vanilla filling. This one’s a party hit.
Red velvet cakes, vanilla glaze, cream cheese filling, and mini chocolate chips.
Everyone’s favorite with chocolate cakes and vanilla filling. A true Pennsylvania classic.
Custom Whoopie Pies
You can create your own custom Pennsylvania Whoopie Pies by first selecting the cake flavors, then a glaze, toppings, and fillings. These are all made by hand from scratch, and eating each one is its own special event. You can make hundreds of different combinations! Check out our menu below, then fill out the form to order.
To create your own custom Whoopie Pies, choose a cake for the top and bottom, then choose your glaze, toppings, and filling.
1. Whoopie Pie Cakes
2. Whoopie Pie Glaze
3. Whoopie Pie Toppings
Mini Chocolate Chips
Chocolate-Covered Coffee Beans
4. Whoopie Pie Filling
The possibilities are endless!
Prices: $2.50 per Whoopie Pie, with a minimum order of 1 dozen.
Note: We can currently do a minimum of 1 dozen per flavor combination. Discounts available for bulk order. Prices subject to change.
Don’t see what you’re looking for? Ask anyway, and maybe we’ll give it a try!
Order Whoopie Pies Online By Letting Us Know What You’d Like:
Our Homemade Whoopie Pies Are Made From Scratch
When people see our Whoopie Pies, they tend to say things like “whoa,” “wow,” or “(inaudible chewing noise)”. Not because our Whoopie Pies are huge… in fact, they’re no bigger than what you would see at a typical farmer’s market. We tested a number of sizes and came up with one that is realistic to eat in one sitting without needing to toss the rest or feel like you can’t eat again for the week. You’ll be able to enjoy every bite and be completely satisfied.
The thing that sets them apart is that they’re more than just cake and filling. Ok, both of those are super important… both the cake and filling are made from scratch by hand in small batches, and strictly taste tested. If they’re not perfect, we don’t use them. This means we eat a lot of Whoopie Pies when we’re trying out a new flavor so we can get it just right, but hey, we’re not complaining!
What sets our Whoopie Pies apart is the number of ways you can customize them. First, add a homemade glaze of either vanilla, chocolate or caramel. Seriously, try the caramel. The glaze acts a food-glue that holds everything together. We put enough on that you’ll be able to love it, but not too much, so it won’t overpower the rest.
Next, add some toppings. Crushed oreo? Sure. Sprinkles/Jimmies/Rainbows/Whatever else you want to call them? Yep. From crushed pretzels to toasted coconut, we’re sure to have something to add some pazazz to your Whoopie Pie. Go crazy, get creative, and see what kind of masterpiece you can make.
Then pick your filling. If you’re paralyzed by the choices, remember that classic vanilla goes with everything. Feeling more adventurous? The cinnamon-coffee is a must, especially paired with chocolate-covered espresso beans.
Don’t Take Our Word For It
Sure, we think these are the best Whoopie Pies you’ll ever have, or at least equally as amazing as those ones you had as a kid (hey, we’re not out to shatter your favorite memories here!). But don’t take our word for it. Check out some of our reviews, like this one:
Delicious Whoppie Pies today! Thank you! My mother in law, the critic of all baked goods, kept saying how much she loved that it was real Whoppie Pie cream and not frosting… I couldn’t believe how much she liked them! – Kristy Ann, Chambersburg PA
You Can Call Them Gobs If You Want To
Whoopie Pies vs Gobs. Is there a difference? Apparently, a bakery in Johnstown owns the trademark on the term “Gobs.” Not very many people realize this, and so the term “gobs” gets thrown around interchangeably with Whoopie Pies. If you live near the Pittsburgh area, you might call them gobs. If you’re at a Sheetz near Pittsburgh, you’ll add a z to get gobz. If you’re in Pennsylvania or Maine, they’re Whoopie Pies. And if you’re anywhere else, you might not have any idea what to call them because it’s highly possible you’ve never seen them before.
Call them whatever you want… we call them delicious.